As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Blackout Curtains vs Cellular Shades vs Roller Shades (2026 Comparison)
If you’re weighing blackout curtains against cellular or roller shades in 2026, this refreshed head-to-head looks at how heavy velvet drapes perform compared with other common window treatments — and tests three Lazzzy curtain SKUs so you can choose quickly. Read on if you care about light control, thermal performance, look and care. We selected these products for consistent fabric quality, clear blackout/thermal claims and broad length options so you can compare premium, mid-range and budget choices side-by-side.
Quick Answer
If you want a luxurious, room-darkening curtain, the Lazzzy Blackout Velvet Gold 108" (ASIN B09Y1LF6RK) is the top pick for style and thermal performance. For value-conscious buyers choose the Lazzzy Green 90" (ASIN B09YLWHJVD); for the tightest budget the Lazzzy Beige 84" (ASIN B07GV9N3V9) balances softness and light control.
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
Select 2-3 products to compare side-by-side
| Compare | Product | CozyMeter Score | Price Tier | Key Feature | Best For | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lazzzy Velvet Gold 108"
|
Premium | 70–80% blackout luxury velvet | Formal rooms, tall windows, insulation | Check Price | ||
Lazzzy Velvet Green 90"
|
Mid-Range | 70–80% blackout, stylish color | Best balance of price, style, and function | Check Price | ||
Lazzzy Beige Velvet 84"
|
Budget | 75% blackout, super soft | Tight budgets & small/standard windows | Check Price |
1. Lazzzy Blackout Velvet Gold Thermal Insulated Curtains 108 Inch Extra Long Drapes for Bedroom Living Room Window Treatments Grommet Luxury Drapes Set of 2 Panels Gold Brown
A premium-feeling velvet drape built for extra-long windows, the 108" Gold panels combine a plush look with thermal benefits. Expect stronger visual impact and better coverage for tall windows compared with the shorter options in this lineup.
Key Specs
- Material: Durable velvet (polyester blend)
- Size: 52" wide x 108" long (pair)
- Light control: 70–80% blackout (room darkening)
- Care: Machine washable (cold, gentle) and tumble dry low
Pros
- More dramatic, luxurious drape than shorter panels
- Better thermal insulation vs lighter rollers or shades
- Superior style and room coverage compared with the budget 84" option
Cons
- Heavier panels need a sturdy rod and hardware
- Not a full blackout solution for total darkness in some installations
Best For: Formal rooms, tall windows, insulation
Check Latest Price on Amazon2. Lazzzy Blackout Velvet Green Thermal Insulated Curtains 90 Inch Long Drapes for Bedroom Window Treatments Grommet Living Room Drapes Set of 2 Panels Olive Sage
The 90" olive/sage panels deliver the same velvet texture and room-darkening performance as the premium unit but at a more approachable price point. They work well in bedrooms or living rooms where you want a stylish look without paying premium for extra length.
Key Specs
- Material: Durable velvet textured fabric
- Size: 52" wide x 90" long (pair)
- Light control: 70–80% blackout (room darkening)
- Care: Machine washable (cold) and tumble dry low
Pros
- Better value than the premium 108" while keeping similar fabric quality
- Attractive color options that match many decor styles
- Good middle ground for insulation vs roller shades
Cons
- Shorter than the 108" option — may not suit tall windows
- Still not a guaranteed full blackout for every window frame
Best For: Best balance of price, style, and function
Check Latest Price on Amazon3. Lazzzy Beige Velvet Curtains 84 Inches Long Thermal Insulated Drapes for Living Room Bedroom Room Darkening Window Treatments Light Reducing Super Soft Luxury Rod Pocket 2 Panels Cream Beige
The 84" cream/beige panels are the budget-friendly pick and are frequently praised for softness and color accuracy. They give solid room-darkening and thermal benefits at the lowest price tier in this group.
Key Specs
- Material: 100% polyester velvet
- Size: 52" wide x 84" long (pair)
- Light control: ~75% blackout (room darkening)
- Care: Machine washable cold, tumble dry
Pros
- Most budget-friendly of the three with soft, luxurious feel
- Good color accuracy and appearance for the price
- Easier to hang on standard rods than heavier premium panels
Cons
- Less coverage and slightly lower blackout percentage than longer models
- Potential durability questions vs heavier premium velvet over long term
Best For: Tight budgets & small/standard windows
Check Latest Price on AmazonWhich One Should You Choose?
If overall style and the deepest coverage for tall windows matter most → Lazzzy Velvet Gold 108" (B09Y1LF6RK). It gives the most dramatic drape and better full-window coverage than shorter pairs. If you want the best mix of price, color choices and fabric quality → Lazzzy Velvet Green 90" (B09YLWHJVD) is the balanced pick. If budget is tight or you have standard-height windows and want softness at the lowest cost → Lazzzy Beige Velvet 84" (B07GV9N3V9). For maximum insulation or complete blackout in unusually shaped windows, pair a curtain with a cellular or roller shade — curtains for style, shades for airtight control.
Best for Specific Scenarios
- Tall, formal rooms: Lazzzy Velvet Gold 108" because the extra length and heavy drape create a luxurious, tailored look and better coverage.
- Bedrooms with moderate budgets: Lazzzy Velvet Green 90" because it balances cost, color options and room-darkening performance.
- Renters or standard windows: Lazzzy Beige Velvet 84" because it’s the most affordable, machine-washable, and still delivers softness and good light control.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much light do these curtains block?
Lazzzy velvet panels are described as room-darkening: the 90" and 108" versions state 70–80% light reduction while the 84" option lists about 75%. They significantly reduce glare and daylight but may not create total blackout in every installation unless mounted to cover the frame tightly.
Are these curtains machine washable?
Yes. All three Lazzzy velvet panels list machine wash care (cold, gentle cycle) and tumble dry low; heavier panels may benefit from gentle handling and steaming to remove wrinkles after washing.
Should I choose curtains or shades for energy savings?
Cellular shades are typically the best single-piece option for insulation due to their honeycomb structure; however, heavy thermal curtains like these velvet panels can also reduce heat loss and drafts — pairing curtains with shades gives the best overall energy performance.
How We Selected These Products
Our recommendations are based on data-driven analysis: we evaluated 279586+ products across 40813+ brands using a composite scoring system that weighs rating (40%), review volume (30%), price value (20%), and demand signals (10%). Every product is ranked by data, not opinions.
Last updated: May 19, 2026
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
CozyMeter Score is our editorial ranking based on a composite analysis of product quality, value, and verified customer sentiment. Click through to Amazon for current pricing, availability, and live customer reviews.