As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Honeycomb Shades vs Blackout Panels vs Thermal Drapes: Fall Energy & Noise Test (2026)
If you want to cut heating costs and quiet the house this fall, this head-to-head compares two popular blackout/thermal drapery options and a close sibling so you can choose quickly. You’ll learn how NICETOWN’s premium thermal blackout drapes stack up against LEMOMO’s budget blackout panels in real-world energy and noise terms, plus which options are easiest to install in rentals. Products were chosen from best-selling curtain styles with fabrics and features shoppers most praise—light blocking, thermal performance, material, and install flexibility.
Quick Answer
For fall energy savings and noise reduction, NICETOWN Thick Blackout Curtain and Drapes (B07T18WMYQ) is the top pick for insulation and sound dampening; LEMOMO Blackout Curtains (B0BJ1VWTJ3) are the best budget choice offering strong blackout performance and easy rental-friendly installs.
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
Select 2-3 products to compare side-by-side
| Compare | Product | CozyMeter Score | Price Tier | Key Feature | Best For | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NICETOWN Thick Blackout
|
Premium | Heavy, velvety thermal blackout fabric | Rooms needing strong insulation & style | Check Price | ||
LEMOMO Blackout (Beige)
|
Budget | Triple-weave thermal blackout fabric | Budget buyers who need strong blackout | Check Price | ||
LEMOMO Blackout (Grey)
|
Budget | Same triple-weave in versatile grey | Those wanting a neutral look on a budget | Check Price |
1. NICETOWN Thick Blackout Curtain and Drapes - (52 x 120, Royal Purple, Pack of 2) Thermal Insulated Grommet Top Window Draperies for Bedroom, Block Out Light Curtain Panel
NICETOWN’s thick polyester drapes feel upscale and are designed to block 85–99% of light while adding thermal insulation and sound reduction. They’re the best option if you want the most fabric mass (better for energy savings and acoustic dampening) and a luxurious look.
Key Specs
- Material: 100% polyester
- Panel size: 52" x 120" (per panel)
- Grommet top with 1.6" inner diameter
- Light blocking: 85%–99%; machine washable
Pros
- Heavier, softer fabric gives better insulation and noise reduction than the LEMOMO panels
- More upscale look and drape, praised for material quality and color fidelity
- Machine washable and designed for thermal energy savings
Cons
- Premium price compared with LEMOMO budget options
- Heavier panels may need sturdier rods and larger mounting clearance
Best For: Rooms needing strong insulation & style
Check Latest Price on Amazon2. LEMOMO Blackout Curtains 66 x 95 inch/Beige Curtains Set of 2 Panels/Thermal Insulated Room Darkening Bedroom Curtains
LEMOMO’s beige panels use a triple-weave polyester construction that blocks most light and helps with seasonal temperature control at a much lower price. Customers like the value, color, and look, though thickness and edge light control can vary by color and window fit.
Key Specs
- Material: 100% polyester (triple weave)
- Panel size: 66" x 95" (per panel)
- 8 metal grommets, 1.6" inner diameter
- Energy-saving and noise-reducing claims; machine washable
Pros
- Strong value for money—effective blackout performance comparable to pricier panels
- Lightweight, easier to hang on tension rods for rental-friendly installs
- Multiple colors and sizes; praised for look and material quality
Cons
- Thickness and blackout performance receive mixed feedback versus heavier drapes
- Edge light leakage and long-term sturdiness debated by some customers
Best For: Budget buyers who need strong blackout
Check Latest Price on Amazon3. LEMOMO Blackout Curtains 66 x 95 inch/Grey Curtains Set of 2 Panels/Thermal Insulated Room Darkening Bedroom Curtains
This grey LEMOMO set offers the same triple-weave thermal fabric as the beige set with a neutral color that suits most decors. It’s an economical way to get room darkening and some thermal benefit, but watch for the same mixed reports on thickness and light bleed at edges.
Key Specs
- Material: 100% polyester (triple weave)
- Panel size: 66" x 95" (per panel)
- 8 metal grommets, 1.6" inner diameter
- Noise reducing and thermal insulated; machine washable
Pros
- Affordable neutral option that hides light well in many rooms
- Lightweight and easy to pair with non-permanent rods for rentals
- Good value and looking fabric according to buyers
Cons
- May be thinner than premium drapes—durability and thickness are debated
- May allow light at the seams and require additional layering for full blackout
Best For: Those wanting a neutral look on a budget
Check Latest Price on AmazonWhich One Should You Choose?
If you want the best fall insulation and noise reduction with a premium look, buy NICETOWN Thick Blackout Curtain and Drapes (B07T18WMYQ) — its heavier polyester weave and denser drape make it the most effective single-piece choice for energy savings and sound dampening. If budget is tight and you still need strong blackout performance plus easy rental installs, choose LEMOMO Blackout Curtains (Beige) (B0BJ1VWTJ3). If you want a neutral option that’s visually versatile on a budget, the LEMOMO Grey set (B0BJ1Y639T) provides the same value and color flexibility. For rentals where drilling is forbidden, favor tension rods or no-drill shades and consider layering a budget panel over a honeycomb shade for the best of both worlds.
Best for Specific Scenarios
- Maximum energy savings & noise dampening: NICETOWN (B07T18WMYQ) because heavier fabric and denser drape trap heat and reduce sound more effectively than thinner panels.
- Tight budget, good blackout: LEMOMO Beige (B0BJ1VWTJ3) because it delivers room-darkening and thermal benefits at lower cost and is praised for value and look.
- Neutral decor and rental flexibility: LEMOMO Grey (B0BJ1Y639T) because the neutral tone blends easily and the lighter panels are easier to hang with non-permanent hardware.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do blackout curtains really save on heating bills in fall?
Yes — heavier blackout or thermal curtains reduce heat loss through windows by adding a layer of insulation. The effect is strongest when panels are close to the window or when you layer a cellular shade with a drape. Results vary with fabric weight, fit (covering the whole window and sides), and single vs layered installs.
Can I install these curtains in a rental without drilling?
Often yes. Many shoppers use tension rods or no-drill curtain rod kits to hang grommet-top panels. Choosing wider panels and extending the rod beyond the frame helps reduce edge light and drafts without permanent hardware. Always check your lease and product dimensions before buying.
Which is quieter: honeycomb shades or thick blackout drapes?
Thick blackout drapes typically provide better broadband sound dampening because of their mass, but cellular honeycomb shades excel at reducing heat transfer thanks to trapped air. For the best combo, pair an inside-mounted cellular shade with an outer drape to improve both insulation and noise reduction.
How We Selected These Products
Our recommendations are based on data-driven analysis: we evaluated 279586+ products across 40813+ brands using a composite scoring system that weighs rating (40%), review volume (30%), price value (20%), and demand signals (10%). Every product is ranked by data, not opinions.
Last updated: October 11, 2026
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
CozyMeter Score is our editorial ranking based on a composite analysis of product quality, value, and verified customer sentiment. Click through to Amazon for current pricing, availability, and live customer reviews.